A few people have alerted me to this video of toddlers and you can watch as a little boy hugs a little girl multiple times and each time he does, she pushes him away. A few of the times, he seems to be prompted to continue by the person with the camera. It’s a full two minutes and nothing changes – he hugs her, she pushes him away, he gets up and hugs her again and she pushes him away again.
Clearly this isn’t street harassment because they know each other and it isn’t sexual harassment because they’re toddlers and don’t have an understanding of all that, but it is a problematic situation in which adults are standing by and letting (encouraging?) this little boy to do something the girl doesn’t want him to do and then instead of helping her use her words to tell him to stop, they’re letting her push him down over and over.
The Good Men Project linked to the video via the How to Be a Dad’s site, where the author labels the post “My Life with Women” and writes, “This one symbolizes every attempt I’ve ever made at relationships with the fairer sex… …. …. until my wife.”
The he writes, “I could be the misogynist here and make some comments about just how badly the lady little treats this fine, young man, but women are pretty great. Maybe this kid needs to get a job, buy a sweet ride (Power Wheels, perhaps?) and learn some Karate, proving himself a worthy love interest?”
And I find that very problematic. Implying that this little toddler and all women who reject men are stuck-up, bitchy, and only after good-looking or rich men is harmful. Instead of looking at the actions and saying, this girl doesn’t want to be hugged, they are focusing on the poor boy and how mean she is. She may have 10 reasons or only 1 for why she doesn’t want to be hugged by him and all of them are valid and should be respected.
No means no, even when you’re a toddler. Especially when you’re a toddler. Fifteen percent of sexual assault and abuse victims are under age 12. Teaching kids how to protect themselves at a very young age is crucial to helping them know how to prevent or get help if they are victimized and can teach them skills they can use all of their life.
This attitude that women owe men attention no matter what contributes to how, when some men are ignored or rejected by the women they harass on the street, they call them a bitch, a ho, throw trash at them, chase them, or tell them they were ugly anyway. Instead of thinking logically about all the reasons why a woman may not respond positively to a man who hollers at her on the street, men feel it is an affront on their masculinity and lash out.
Another problematic aspect of the video is the number of people who applauded how persistent the kid is. Some people in the comments of posts talked about being disappointed he never got her in the end. Guess what, you don’t always “get the girl” in the end. No means no! 1,006,970 women and 370,990 men are stalked annually in the U.S. We need to teach kids, especially boys because they are the bulk of the stalkers, not to follow or keep hugging etc women and girls who clearly don’t want that attention.
So those are my thoughts on the video, what are yours?
Emily R says
Holly, I think you’re spot on. The little girl clearly looks pissed, she’s made it very clear that she doesn’t want his attention and everyone seems to discount the importance of that. She may just find him annoying, but the lesson it potentially teaches to each of them – that her opinion doesn’t matter and she just has to put up with these things, and that he should keep bothering someone else because other people think it’s cute – is really problematic. It’s so important to allow children to establish their own boundaries and respect when they say no, even if it’s an (apparently) harmless kiss from Grandma. All touch should be consented to.
Alan says
As a metaphor All your points are really good and valid. I love how articulate you are and thought provoking. You can certainly imagine that at least initially that the boy was being encourage to say he was sorry for some incident that happened before the filming started, but then not sure what happened for the next too minutes! I guess “cute” is in the eye of the beholder and the parent/other adult got a little carried away. As the parent of three grown daughters, you point out such an important role parents have to put the need to teach their children before they satisfy their own egos or self-interests.
Jo L. says
Agree 100%! I felt the same way when I saw that video making the rounds on Facebook.
beckie says
I often wish I could rewind and raise my girls differently more protective of their gender and their rights, this video makes that wish even stronger. I love all the points you all are making. Here’s to safer, fairer future for girls.